My initial impression of the K’Tan can be summed up in a word: minimalist. It is comprised of 2 thin, stretchy pieces of fabric held together with a loop, and an additional “sash” of the same material. Cleverly, the sash also doubles as a carrying bag. The K’Tan is easy to throw into a bag and transport; while many carriers share that fact (such as a ring sling), others can be a mess of buckles, tails and straps, and may not come with anything to store or carry them in (but this is easily remedied with a simple drawstring bag, like a shoe bag). The double-function sash-and-bag feature, combined with the simplicity of the K’Tan’s design, is appealing.
Of key importance is that K’Tan is that it comes in sizes. It suggests to size down if you are between sizes, which I did. While the sizing is necessary for such a design, I do think it is a negative aspect as well, because the carrier can only be used by another person of the same size, whereas SSC’s are generally adjustable for multiple people to wear baby (such as both moms and/or dads), and wraps are completely versatile and customizable. I found sizing down to be the right fit for me, though I cannot imagine it would grow well with my baby, even with the stretchy fabric.
Putting on the K’Tan looked a bit confusing, but a quick look at the website provided easy instructions, and I proceeded with the “Hug” position. My tired baby quickly fell asleep. At 15 lbs, he is a big baby for his age, but I still felt fairly supported in the carrier. (I do think if I had a smaller baby I might find it not quite supportive enough and too stretchy – mine fits pretty snugly.) The thinness of the fabric does make it a little less supportive than I’d like, and so while it was comfortable, it was not enough for me –the ring in the back that connects the loops also prevents the fabric from being completely spread out (to distribute baby’s weight and maximize comfort, which can be done with a wrap). It also lacks the padding of SSC’s or the width of wraps, and I doubt I, personally, would find it comfortable for a child much larger than mine. (I did see someone at the zoo recently wearing a much bigger child, so maybe it would be fine!) However, he slept happily in it, and I did not really get sore the way I do with a ring sling. It is also extremely easy to take off, which not all carriers are – a fact I appreciate when baby wakes up crying and I need to get him out right away.
Conclusion: great for some, but not for me
In sum, I found the K’Tan to be moderately to very comfortable and easy to use, with a basic design that makes it quite appealing as a cross-over carrier, if you can accept some limitations. It’s a good option for those who are fine with the limits and cannot purchase multiple carriers, who do not want to deal with the learning curve of wraps, the buckles and straps of SSC’s and mei tai’s, and want something more physically balanced than a ring sling. But, while I think it is a great hybrid carrier, it will not replace, or be added to, my existing stash. I still find wraps to be more comfortable, and I appreciate the versatility of them, which, for me, makes the trial and error of learning worthwhile. While both SSC’s and the K’Tan are limited in the types of carries that can be used, I find SSC’s more supportive, and they’re usually adjustable; I don’t like that my husband could not use the K’Tan. I also feel my ring sling is far more supportive for a big baby with its silk fabric than the stretchiness of the K’Tan, and is just as easy to transport. Thus, I am happy enough with my current stash to not add the K’Tan – but I’d likely buy it for a friend as a shower gift, since, while limited, it encompasses many good features from several types of carriers.
NOTE TO READERS FROM CATHY: I am lucky to live in a community with a great babywearing support group! Our support group offers free help and support to caregivers wishing to learn how to wear their babies. It also offers a lending library of carriers where people can try a carrier out before they buy. Baby K'Tan VERY generously donated the carrier used in this review to the community's local lending library in exchange for a fair and honest review. The oppinions expressed in this review are the author's own and have not been influenced by the donation. I wish to thank Baby K'Tan for their generosity.